828 I St, Arcata, CA 95521 707-630-5100
828 I St, Arcata, CA 95521 707-630-5100
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Eat with us!

food on a plate }
food on a plate

October Menu - Subject to availability

Slice of Humboldt Pie is

 NOW ACCEPTING 

Christmas Pie Orders

Christmas

We will take orders until we feel we are at order capacity for each day. 

The day before the Holiday will fill up first.

Week of Christmas hours:

Tuesday, Dec 20th – 11am – 8pm

Wednesday, Dec 21st – 11am – 8pm

Thursday, Dec 22nd – 11am – 8pm

Friday, Dec 23rd – 11am – 8pm

Saturday, Dec 24th - (Christmas Eve) 11am – 4pm

*Eureka Natural Foods in Eureka & McKinleyville will have select pies before the Holidays, if you are not able to order from us in time, or able to make it in to pick up. 

*You can use our website/Instagram/or our app as well to place orders.  You will need to pick the time and date of when you would like to pick up.

*Ordering will fill up, so order early.  The days right before the Holidays fill up first.  

*Don’t worry if you need to pick up on a different day! Our pies are great for 4 days.  

*Even though ordering will fill up and we will not accept any additional orders, we will make plenty of pies for first come, first served basis on the pick-up days.  We will not be able to hold pies for guests on the Tuesday and Wednesday before Thanksgiving or the Thursday, Friday, or Saturday before Christmas.

*Slice of Humboldt Pie will be CLOSED from Sunday, Jan 1st – 16th for cleaning, repairs and a little time with family and friends after working during the Holidays.

  • 9" Pie Shells

    9" Crimped Pie Crust $4

    9" Bottom & Top Flat Crust $6

    9" GF Crimped Pie Crust $6

    9" GF Top & Bottom Flat Crust $8

  • Spiked Eggnog

    Our pie version of the classic boozy holiday drink! A creamy rum spiked custard finished with whipped cream and sprinkled with nutmeg, featuring Humboldt Distillery Organic Rum.

    Reg $30

    Gluten Free $34

  • Chocolate Peppermint

    Chocolate brownie-like pie with a hint of peppermint, finished with a ring of whipped cream and dusted with candy cane bits.

    Reg $27

    Gluten Free $31

  • Gingerbread Cream

    This pie has the warm spiced flavor of gingerbread, topped with whipped cream.

    Reg $29

    Gluten Free $33

  • Blackberry

    Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through. Contains egg wash

    Reg $30

    Gluten Free $36

    Vegan $30

    GF/V $36

  • Chocolate Silk

    Light silky chocolate mousse, made with Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate (Eureka, Ca), mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate.

    Reg $27

    Gluten Free $31

  • Peanut Butter Fudge

    This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.

    Reg $27

  • Traditional Apple

    Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Vegan

    Reg $27

    Gluten Free $33

  • Lemon Raspberry

    Tangy lemon curd with a layer fresh raspberry compote and topped with dollops of whipped cream.

    Reg $27

    Gluten Free/Vegan $31

  • Pumpkin

    Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.

    Reg $27

    Gluten Free $31

    Vegan $30

    GF/V $34

  • Pumpkin Walnut

    Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.

    Reg $29

    Gluten Free $36

    Vegan $35

    GF/V $39

  • Pecan

    Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crust.

    Reg $30

    Gluten Free $34

  • Black Bottom Pecan

    Our pecan pie with a layer of chocolate ganache.

    Regular $32

    Gluten Free $36

  • Whipped Cream

    Side of whipped cream

    $4.50

  • Vanilla Ice Cream (1.75qt)

    Umqoua vanilla ice cream

    $8

Hand Pies

*We use antibiotic & hormone free, Humboldt grass-fed beef and Rocky’s free-range chicken in all of our savory pies.

  • Add a dipping sauce of Cumin Lime, Ranch, Blue Cheese $0.75 - $1

  • V - Vegan

    GF - Gluten Free

    DF - Dairy Free

  • GF/V/DF Veggie Curry

    Potatoes, peas, and carrots in a warm yellow coconut curry sauce, in a gluten free and dairy free crust.

    $4.50

  • GF/DF Sloppy Joe

    Humboldt Grass-Fed ground beef, onions, tomato sauce, and seasonings, made into our version of a sloppy joe and put into a neat not so sloppy pastry.

    $4.50

  • Pulled Pork & Green Chili

    Smoky, tender pulled pork simmered with roasted chili peppers and spices. Don't forget to add a side of cumin lime dipping sauce!

    $3.75

  • Chicken Curry

    Shredded chicken, potatoes, peas, and carrots in a warm yellow coconut curry sauce.

    $3.75

  • Mushroom & Kale

    Cremini mushrooms, kale, garlic, and rosemary sautéed in olive oil.

    $3.75

  • Cheese Steak

    Sauteed strips of Humboldt Grass-fed steak, green bell peppers and onions, smothered in provolone cheese.

    $3.75

  • Veggie Curry

    Potatoes, peas, and carrots in a warm yellow coconut curry sauce.

    $3.75

  • Sloppy Joe

    Humboldt Grass-Fed ground beef, onions, tomato sauce, and seasonings, made into our version of a sloppy joe and put into a neat not so sloppy pastry.

    $3.75

Pot Pies

  • Chicken Pot Pie*

    Roasted chicken, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce.

    Personal $7.50

    *GF - Personal $9.50

    Family size - Frozen or Hot (must order 1 hr. in advance for hot) $28

    *GF - Family Size - Frozen or Hot (must order 1 hr. in advance for hot) $34

  • Veggie Pot Pie

    Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a hearty veggie gravy.

    Personal $7

    Family size - Frozen or Hot (must order 1 hr. in advance for hot) $27

Pie Crusts

  • Pie Crusts

    Formed crust with pie tin $4

    Formed gluten free crust with pie tin $6

    Unformed bottom crust & top crust with pie tin $6

    Unformed gluten free bottom crust & top crust with pie tin $8

Sweet Pies

Get Your Pie Whole or By the Slice!

  • *Marked pies are available Gluten Free in-house.

  • *Blackberry

    Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through.

    Slice $6.25

    Whole $30

    GF/V Slice $7

    GF/V Whole $36

    Vegan Slice $6.25

    Vegan Whole $30

  • Spiked Eggnog

    Our pie version of the classic boozy holiday drink! A creamy rum spiked custard finished with whipped cream and sprinkled with nutmeg, featuring Humboldt Distillery Organic Rum. *Gluten Free available to order 24hrs. in advance.

    Slice $6.25

    Whole $30

  • Chocolate Peppermint

    Chocolate brownie-like pie with a hint of peppermint, finished with a ring of whipped cream and dusted with candy cane bits. *Gluten Free available for order 24hrs. in advance.

    Slice $5.75

    Whole $27

  • Gingerbread Cream

    This pie has the warm spiced flavor of gingerbread, topped with whipped cream. Gluten Free may be ordered 24hrs. in advance.

    Slice $6

    Whole $29

  • Peanut Butter Fudge

    This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.

    Slice $5.75

    Whole $27

  • Buttermilk

    This is a creamy centered pie with a golden caramelized top, just the right amount of sweetness. Gluten Free available to be ordered 24hrs in advance.

    Slice $5.75

    Whole $27

  • *Chocolate Silk

    Light silky chocolate mousse, made with Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate (Eureka, Ca), mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate. Gluten free available in house.

    Slice $5.75

    Whole $27

    GF Slice $6.50

    GF Whole $31

  • Traditional Apple

    Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Vegan. Gluten free available may be ordered 24 hrs in advance.

    Slice $5.75

    Whole $27

  • *Lemon Raspberry

    Tangy lemon curd with a layer fresh raspberry compote and topped with dollops of whipped cream.

    Slice $5.75

    Whole $27

    GF Slice $6.50

    GF Whole $31

  • Add a scoop of ice cream or whipped cream to your slice!

    Vanilla Ice Cream - with a slice of pie $2.25

    Dollop of Fresh Vanilla whipped cream $0.75

    Side of Fresh Vanilla whipped cream (14 oz.) $5

    Just the Ice Cream? No problem! $3

Salads

Small or Large Salads available

  • *Pick one house made dressing for your salad, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, or Balsamic Vinaigrette (Vegan).

  • Mixed Green Salad

    Mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onions and “croutons” – savory butter crust with chives. Add Rocky's chicken breast.

    $6.50

    $10.75

  • Fruit and Walnut Salad

    Mixed greens with sliced granny smith apples, Cypress Grove Fresh Chèvre, walnuts, red onions, and “croutons” – savory butter crust with chives. Add Rocky's chicken breast.

    $7.50

    $11.75

Drinks

  • Canned or Bottled Soda

    Coke, Sprite, Orange Fanta, Squirt, Diet Coke

    $2

  • Organic Hot Apple Cider

    $3.75

    Add whipped cream $0.75

  • Cold Brewed Loose-Leaf Black Tea

    16 oz. $2.50

    16oz. $3.50

  • Organic Cold Brewed Coffee

    12 oz $2.50

    16 oz $3.50

  • Organic Hot Coffee – French Roast

    12oz. $2

    16oz. $2.75

  • Hot Loose-Leaf Tea

    *Smith Tea Makers – Portland, OR.

    12 oz. $2

    16 oz. $2.75

  • Lord Bergamot

    (Black Tea) - A flavor somewhat superior to traditional Earl Grey.

  • Brahmin

    (Black Tea) - This is a perfect breakfast tea.

  • Mao Feng Shui

    (Green Tea) - This tea is exceptionally rich in antioxidants.

  • Fez

    (Green Tea) - Rare green teas from China combined with aromatic spearmint grown in the Pacific Northwest and a hint of lemon myrtle.

  • Meadow

    (Chamomile) - Caffeine Free

  • Peppermint Leaves

    (Sourced from OR) Caffeine Free

  • Milk (8 oz)

    $2.25

  • Organic Apple Juice (8 oz)

    $2.25

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!