828 I St, Arcata, CA 95521 707-630-5100
828 I St, Arcata, CA 95521 707-630-5100
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Eat with us!

food on a plate
food on a plate

November Menu

Empanandas

*We use antibiotic & hormone free, Humboldt grass- fed beef, Rocky’s free-range chicken, and beeler’s natural pork in all of our savory pies.

  • Add a dipping sauce of Cumin Lime, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Cranberry Sauce, or Turkey Gravy $0.50

  • Sloppy Joe

    Our version of sloppy joe, in a neat transportable pastry. Made with Humboldt Grass-Fed beef. *Gluten Free/Dairy Free is available in house.

    $3.65

    Gluten Free $4.15

  • Hot Wing

    Shredded Rocky’s chicken in a spicy house-made hot wing sauce. Includes your choice of Bleu Cheese, Ranch or extra hot wing sauce

    $4.15

  • Chicken Coconut Curry

    Rocky’s chicken, potatoes, peas and carrots in a yellow coconut curry sauce.

    $3.65

  • Veggie Coconut Curry

    Potatoes, peas and carrots in a yellow coconut curry. *Gluten Free/Dairy Free is available in house.

    $3.65

    Gluten Free $4.15

  • Pulled Pork & Green Chili*

    Smoky, tender pulled pork simmered with roasted chili peppers and spices.

    $3.75

    Gluten Free $4.25

  • Roasted Vegetable

    Lightly seasoned, roasted yams, zucchini, yellow squash, eggplant, red bell peppers and garlic. *Vegan available in house.

    $3.65

    Vegan $4.15

  • Vegan Kale & Mushroom

    Cremini mushrooms, kale, garlic, and rosemary sautéed in olive oil.

    $4.15

Pot Pies

  • Chicken Pot Pie*

    Roasted chicken, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy sauce.

    Personal $7

    *Personal - gluten free $9

    Family Size – Limited amount made daily $26

  • Veggie Pot Pie

    Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a hearty veggie gravy.

    Personal $6.50

    Family size (traditional) must be ordered 48 hrs. in advance $26

  • The Left Over

    Roasted Mary’s turkey, mash potatoes, gravy, topped with flavorful stuffing and served with a side of cranberry sauce or a side of hot turkey gravy.

    5" Personal $8.50

    9" Family Size - must be ordered 48 hrs. in advance $32

Pie Crusts

  • Traditional Pie Cookies

    Our traditional pie crust dusted with raw sugar.

    $5.50

  • Cinnamon Pie Cookies

    Our traditional pie crust dusted with raw sugar and cinnamon.

    $5.50

  • Pie Crusts

    Frozen or Prebaked crusts
    *Prebaked crusts must be ordered 24 hrs. in advance.

    Formed crust with pie tin $4

    Formed gluten free crust with pie tin $6

    Unformed crust with pie tin & top $6

    Unformed gluten free crust with pie tin & top $8

Sweet Pies

Get Your Pie Whole or By the Slice!

  • *Marked pies can be made Gluten Free

    Add/slice $0.50

    full pie $4

  • Pumpkin*

    Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices. *Gluten Free available in-house.

    Slice $5

    Whole Pie $22

    *Gluten Free - Slice $5.50

    *Gluten Fee - Whole $26

  • Pumpkin Walnut*

    Our pumpkin pie topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.

    Slice $5.25

    Whole $23

  • Pecan*

    Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crust.

    Slice $5.25

    Whole Pie $23

  • Chocolate Silk*

    Light silky chocolate mousse, made with Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate (Eureka, Ca), mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate.

    Slice $5.50

    Whole Pie $25

    *Gluten Free $6

    *Gluten Free - Whole Pie $29

  • Apple Crumble*

    Thinly sliced local apples topped with a brown sugar oat crumble.

    Slice $5.25

    Whole Pie $23

  • Sour Cherry*

    Whole pitted sour cherries, lightly sweetened, in our traditional pie crust. *Gluten Free/Dairy Free is available in-house.

    Slice $5.25

    Whole Pie $23

    Gluten Free - Slice $5.25

    Gluten Free - Whole $23

  • Hard Apple Cider*

    Apple pie meets cream pie; tart, tangy, sweet and creamy.

    Slice $5.25

    Whole $23

  • Peanut Butter Fudge

    This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.

    Slice $5

    Whole Pie $22

  • Traditional Apple*

    Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Vegan

    Slice $5

    Whole Pie $22

  • Add a scoop of ice cream or whipped cream to your slice!

    Vanilla Ice Cream - with a slice of pie $2

    Dollop of Fresh Vanilla whipped cream $0.50

    Side of Fresh Vanilla whipped cream (14 oz.) $4.50

    Just the Ice Cream? No problem! $3

Salads

Small or Large Salads available

  • *Pick one house made dressing for your salad, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Balsamic Vinaigrette (Vegan), or Local Cassaro Dressing - Green Onion Vinaigrette (Vegan)

    *Add Applewood smoked bacon or Rocky’s chicken breast to your salad. $2

    $4

    Large salads may get 1⁄2 bacon & 1⁄2 chicken $4

  • Mixed Green Salad

    Mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onions and “croutons” – savory butter crust with chives.

    $6

    $10

  • Fruit and Walnut Salad

    Mixed greens with sliced granny smith apples, Cypress Grove Fresh Chèvre, walnuts, red onions, and “croutons” – savory butter crust with chives.

    $7

    $11

Drinks

  • Organic Hot Coffee – French Roast

    Here (12oz.) $2

    To go (12oz.) $2

    To go (16oz.) $2.75

    Refill $0.50

  • Organic Cold Brewed Coffee

    Here (16oz.) $3

    To go (12oz.) $2.50

    To go (16oz.) $3

    Refill $1

  • Hot Loose-Leaf Tea

    *Smith Tea Makers – Portland, OR.

    Here (12 oz.) $2

    To go (16 oz.) $2.75

  • Lord Bergamot

    (Black Tea) - A flavor somewhat superior to traditional Earl Grey.

  • Brahmin

    (Black Tea) - This is a perfect breakfast tea.

  • Mao Feng Shui

    (Green Tea) - This tea is exceptionally rich in antioxidants.

  • Fez

    (Green Tea) - Rare green teas from China combined with aromatic spearmint grown in the Pacific Northwest and a hint of lemon myrtle.

  • Meadow

    (Chamomile) - Caffeine Free

  • Peppermint Leaves

    (Sourced from OR) Caffeine Free

  • Cold Brewed Loose-Leaf Black Tea

    Here (16oz.) $3

    To go (12oz.) $2.50

    To go (16oz.) $3

    Refill $1

  • Fresh Squeezed Lemonade

    Here (16oz.) $3.50

    To go (12oz.) $3

    To go (16oz.) $3.50

    Refill $1

  • Arnold Palmer

    Here (16oz.) $3.50

    To go (12oz.) $3

    To go (16oz.) $3.50

    Refill $1

  • Organic Hot Apple Cider (12 oz.)

    $3.50

    Add whipped cream $0.50

  • Bottled Soda

    Coke, Sprite, Orange Fanta, Squirt, Diet Coke

    $2

  • Milk (8 oz.)

    $2.25

  • Organic Apple Juice (8 oz.)

    $2.25

Last day to pre-order & pay for Thanksgiving pies is Nov. 18th.  

You may pick up your pre-ordered holiday pies at these locations:

Arcata -  at Slice of Humboldt pie

            *In Arcata, we will make additional pies for purchase, but it will be   for first come, first serve only.  We do sell out!

Sun, Nov 24th - 11 am - 8 pm

Mon, Nov 25th - 11 am - 10 pm

Tues, Nov 26th - 11 am - 10 pm

Wed, Nov 27th - 11 am - 6 pm         

Eureka - Old Town Coffee & Chocolates

Henderson Center 

Tues, Nov 26th - 7 am - 5 pm

Wed, Nov 27th - 7 am - 5 pm  

Old Town 

Tues, Nov 26th - 7 am - 9 pm

Wed, Nov 27th - 7 am - 9 pm

Pies

  • Pumpkin

    Creamy rich pumpkin with a perfect balance of warm spices.

    $22

    Gluten Free $26

  • Pumpkin Walnut

    Our pumpkin pie, topped with a buttery walnut streusel topping.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Pecan

    Chopped pecans in a sweet gooey filling, baked in a flaky pie crus

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Chocolate Silk

    Light silky chocolate mousse, made with Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate (Eureka, CA), mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate.

    $25

    Gluten Free $29

  • Apple Crumble

    Thinly sliced apples, topped with a brown sugar oat crumble.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Sour Cherry

    Whole pitted sour cherries, lightly sweetened, in our traditional pie crust.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Hard Apple Cider

    Apple pie meets cream pie; tart, tangy, sweet and creamy.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Peanut Butter Fudge

    This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.

    $22

  • Apple

    Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Vegan

    $22

    Gluten Free $26

Last day to pre-order & pay for Christmas pies is Dec. 16th.  

You may pick up your pre-ordered holiday pies at these locations:

Arcata -  Slice of Humboldt pie

            *In Arcata, we will make additional pies for purchase, but it will be   for first come, first serve only.  We do sell out!

Sat, Dec 21st - 11 am - 11 pm

Sun, Dec 22nd - 11 am - 8 pm

Mon, Dec 23rd - 11 am - 10 pm

Tues, Dec 24th - 11 am - 6 pm         

Eureka - Old Town Coffee & Chocolates 

Henderson Center 

Mon, Dec 23rd - 7 am - 5 pm

Tues, Dec 24th - 7 am - 3 pm

Old Town 

Tues, Nov 26th - 7 am - 9 pm

Wed, Nov 27th - 7 am - 4 pm

Pies

  • Mocha Cream

    A rich coffee chocolate cream topped with coffee whipped cream.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Spiked Eggnog

    Our pie version of the classic boozy holiday drink! A creamy rum spiked custard and finished with a ring of whipped cream.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Chocolate Peppermint

    Chocolate brownie-like pie with a hint of peppermint, finished with a ring of whipped cream and dusted with candy cane bits.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Chocolate Silk

    Light silky chocolate mousse, made with Dick Taylor Craft Chocolate (Eureka, CA), mounded with fluffy whipped cream and shaved chocolate.

    $25

    Gluten Free $29

  • Apple

    Thinly sliced local apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

    $22

    Gluten Fee $26

  • Gingerbread

    This cream pie has the warm spiced flavor of gingerbread, topped with whipped cream.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Lumberjack

    Chopped pecans and thick cut applewood smoked bacon in a gooey maple filling.

    $25

    Gluten Free $29

  • Blackberry

    Blackberries lightly sweetened to let the berries tartness shine through.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Lemon Chess

    Traditional southern lemon curd pie with tangy lemon center and a caramelized top.

    $23

    Gluten Free $27

  • Peanut Butter Fudge

    This pie has a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge and topped with a light fluffy peanut butter cream, and then frozen.

    $22

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!